The 10 Best Syracuse Restaurants: A Local's Guide 2025

Sign up for TLDR Syracuse and get the best of Syracuse, New York, events and hidden gems delivered weekly. Free always 🍊🧂

📩 The next issue drops this week, get on the list now!

Syracuse's dining scene is one of New York's best-kept secrets. From iconic pasta spots to elevated dining experiences, this city delivers culinary experiences that compete with larger cities. Below is an in-depth look at the best Syracuse restaurants that deserve all your attention.

Best Syracuse Restaurants

Pastabilities - A Syracuse and Italian Icon, Where the Line is Always Long

📍Location: 311 S Franklin St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Pastabilities is on everyone’s list when it comes to Syracuse restaurants. Their iconic stretch bread with spicy hot tomato oil is a staple. This signature appetizer alone has people waiting in line to get a taste, and honestly? It’s totally worth it.

The vibes inside are cozy but with date night energy. They've been serving hits since 1982, which explains why locals and visitors alike keep coming back for decades. Their made-in-house pasta dishes just scream quality. Especially the Wicked Chicken Riggies that deliver that perfect spicy creamy combo that'll have you scraping the plate clean.

They are also serving some of the most mouthwatering gluten-free and dairy-free pasta options you'll ever try. Their vegan pesto with gluten-free penne is a mouth-watering and intoxicating experience. The service passes the vibe check, too. Warning: if you don’t plan ahead and make a reservation or add yourself to their queue, wait times can be long (especially on weekends), so either show up super early or come prepared with patience.

The locals’ trick, if possible, hit their lunch on the weekdays if you don’t want to wait. They run a fast, first-come, first-served service where lunch specials are available every day, and the menu features all of the homemade pasta and sauces. Don’t expect to wait longer than 10-15 minutes.

Local Favorites

• Spicy Hot Tomato Oil

• Wicked Chicken Riggies

• Spicy Bolognese

Noble Cellar - Our Most Bougie Pick, but they Never Disappoint

📍 Location: 304 E Onondaga St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Noble Cellar is the definition of "treat yourself." This is the spot where you bring someone you're trying to impress because everything about it screams elevated experience. Located in an old church with the original stained glass windows, the aesthetic is premium, they understood the assignment with a thoughtful interior design that complements the historic architecture.

The food here doesn't just taste good, it's an entire production. Each dish looks like it's ready for its Instagram close-up, but the flavors are the star of the show. Their menu changes with the seasons, keeping things fresh and exciting. They always have an excellent selection of wines to pair with whatever they are serving up.

The staff deserves their flowers too; they are attentive, checking on you throughout your meal, and always ensure everything is perfect. Fair warning, this spot requires planning since reservations can book out weeks in advance, especially for weekends. And yes, it's pricier than your usual dinner spot, but as the reviews confirm, the quality more than justifies the investment

Local Favorites

• Beef Tartare

• Short Rib Sugo

• Rainbow Trout

Kitty Hoyne’s - A Love Letter to Irish Cuisine

📍 Location: 301 W Fayette St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Kitty Hoyne's has been serving Irish pub vibes since 1999, and it's clear why it's remained an absolute staple in Syracuse's dining scene. Named after the owner David's mother, Catherine (Kitty), this place brings genuine Irish hospitality to the heart of Syracuse in the historic Crown Building. You're transported to a pub in Dublin when you walk in.

The atmosphere here is warm lighting, wooden fixtures, and that cozy pub feel that makes you want to stay for "just one more" pint. Their legendary fish and chips deserve all the hype. They are perfectly crispy on the outside, flaky and tender on the inside. The beer selection is perfect, featuring the best Guinness pour in Syracuse that pairs perfectly with their hearty comfort food.

The spirit of the pub traces back to Thomastown, County Kilkenny, Ireland, in the 1920s, and that heritage shapes everything from the menu to the decor. They're not just serving food and drinks, they're delivering the authentic Irish vibes. Whether you're coming for a casual lunch or a full night out, Kitty Hoyne's brings that perfect blend of tradition and good vibes that keeps people coming back.

Local Favorites

• Fish & Chips

• Bangers & Mash

• Irish Meatloaf

Apizza Regionale - Wood Fire Pizza for Days

📍 Location: 260 W Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Wood-fired pizza with that perfect char? Say less. The ingredients are fresh, the flavors are bold, and the vibes are chill. Making it the perfect spot to hang with friends or have a laid-back date night. This is the go-to spot for pizza lovers who care about quality. It’s an experience where quality meets comfort food goals. Their attention to detail in sourcing local and seasonal ingredients means you’re always getting the best of what’s in season, which keeps the specials menu exciting and the flavors popping.

Whether you’re a classic margherita stan or down to try their more adventurous pies, Apizza Regionale delivers consistently. They do not take reservations, so it is advised to show up earlier rather than later if you have a large party, because they are always busy and the wait can get long.

Local Favorites

• The Calabrian

• Rucolo

• Pork Store Arancini

Fish Friar - A Hidden Gem for Seafood

📍 Location: 239 E Genesee Street  Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Lowkey one of Syracuse’s best-kept secrets. Fish Friar is the spot to hit when you want something quick, affordable, and insanely good. Their sandwiches are next-level, packed with flaky, perfectly cooked shrimp/scallops. The fried haddock is crispy without being greasy, and the mushy peas always hit.

The menu keeps it straightforward but never boring. Each bite tastes like it was made with care and respect for the ingredients. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a quick lunch or casual dinner and still feel like you’re treating yourself to something special. If you don’t want to wait, make sure you use their waitlist feature because they can fill up on busy weekends.

If you want fresh seafood vibes without the seafood price tag or fuss, Fish Friar is the plug. It’s casual, it’s tasty, and it hits that perfect sweet spot between comfort food and quality eats. And don’t forget the Swedish fish!

Local Favorites

• Spicy Scallop Roll

• Honey Shrimp Po’Boy

• Fish & Chips

The York - The Stylish Date Night

📍 Location: 247 W Fayette St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

The York is that sleek spot that makes every meal feel like a mini celebration. Whether you’re coming for brunch, dinner, or cocktails, this place knows how to serve up dishes that keep things interesting without getting too wild. Their raw bar alone is worth the trip if you are a seafood fan. You can always get your hands on some oysters year-round here.

The interior is modern and chic, creating an atmosphere that’s perfect for everything from a casual hangout to a special night out. Their cocktail menu is just as thoughtful as their food, with drinks that pair perfectly with the menu.

If you want a spot that does it all with style and flavor, The York is the spot. We recommend booking a reservation here because it is a popular spot and one of the only places in the city that is open on Mondays. Also, did we mention it turns into a club after hours on the weekends? If you want to party, check them out later in your evening after dinner.

Local Favorites

• Oysters from the raw bar

• Bone Marrow

• Short Rib Ravioli

Inka’s - The New Kid on the Block

📍 Location: 201 S Salina St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

If you’re craving a flavor trip that’s different from the usual Syracuse eats, Inka’s is where you need to be. This Peruvian spot brings the heat with dishes like lomo saltado and ceviche that are incredible. The flavors are vibrant, bold, and perfectly balanced. Think tangy, savory, spicy, and fresh all in one bite.

Inka’s isn’t just a meal, it’s a little cultural adventure that proves Syracuse’s food scene is way more diverse than you thought. If you’re down to switch up your usual, this place will rock your world.

Local Favorites

• Tartar De Atun Y Salmon

• Lomo Saltado

• Arroz Con Pollo

Lemon Grass - A Staple in Upscale Syracuse Dining

📍 Location: 113 Walton St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Lemon Grass is the upscale thai spot where every dish is plated like art and tastes even better than it looks. This is not your average takeout joint. It’s a full-on dining experience with bold, complex flavors that hit all the right notes: spicy, sweet, sour, and savory in perfect harmony.

The ingredients are top-tier, and you can tell the chefs put mad respect into every bite. From the crispy spring rolls to the rich, creamy curries, each dish is a flavor bomb that makes you feel fancy without being pretentious. It’s the kind of place you go to when you want to celebrate or just treat yourself to a meal that’s as much about the presentation as it is about the taste.

Plus, the ambiance of their new location is sleek and modern, making it perfect for date nights or catching up with friends over cocktails that are just as thoughtfully crafted as the food. If you’re in the mood to splurge on some next-level Thai, Lemon Grass is the move.

Local Favorites

• Shrimp Dumplings

• Roasted Duck with Orange Tamarind

• Filet Mignon with Green Curry

Water Street Bagel - The Best Bagel in Town

📍 Location: 239 E Water St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Wood-fired bagels? Say less. Water Street Bagel is serving up some of the crispiest, most perfectly chewy bagels in Syracuse. Whether you’re going classic with cream cheese or going all out with lox and toppings, the wood-fired method gives the bagels a unique texture and flavor that’s next-level compared to your average bagel spot.

This place is a morning hotspot, especially when hungover college kids roll in looking for that perfect pick-me-up. The line might get long, but the bagels are worth every minute of the wait. Plus, the staff is friendly and efficient, keeping the energy upbeat even when the place is packed. Lunch is usually a good time to swing by since they can be less busy.

If you want a bagel that’s crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and loaded with fresh, quality toppings, Water Street Bagel is the move.

Local Favorites

• The Western

• The Nova

• The New Yorker

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que - Where the NY BBQ Legend Started

📍 Location: 246 W Willow St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que isn't just eating, it's a cultural moment. This iconic spot has been serving up God-tier BBQ since 1988. The building itself is giving major heritage vibes, dating back to the early 1920s when it housed various barrooms, including the N&H Tavern.

What makes Dino (as the locals call it) absolutely elite is how they've managed to keep it real while still catering to everyone. Their menu is stacked with options for different dietary needs – gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian, without compromising on that authentic BBQ flavor. The fall-off-the-bone ribs and brisket are basically the main characters here, but don't sleep on their wings either – they're legendary for a reason.

The atmosphere is peak authenticity, it's gritty-meets-welcoming in the best possible way. And during summer? The outdoor seating area is great and is dog-friendly, so your fur babies can join the fun. Just remember they don't take reservations, so you'll need to strategize your visit (first-come, first-served is their whole policy). For the planners in the group, they also offer private event spaces upstairs that can host up to 80 people with a full bar, perfect for when you need to flex for a special occasion.

Local Favorites

• Brisket Plate

• Prime Brisket tacos

• Pork Ribs

Final Thoughts

Syracuse restaurants are underrated and deserve some hype. These restaurants aren't just serving meals, they're creating experiences that stay with you. Whether craving comfort food at Pastabilities, authentic BBQ at Dinosaur, elevated dining at Noble Cellar, or Irish pub vibes at Kitty Hoyne's, Syracuse restaurants deliver culinary moments that are worth it. The passion behind these establishments shows in every aspect of their operation, from the carefully crafted menus to the thoughtful service and distinctive atmospheres.

Want more local food guides like this? Sign up for TLDR Syracuse and get the best of Syracuse, New York, bakeries, coffee shops, events, and hidden gems, delivered weekly. Free always 🍊🧂

📩 The next issue drops this week, get on the list now!