The 7 Best Syracuse Coffee Shops: A Local's Guide 2025

Sign up for TLDR Syracuse and get the best of Syracuse, New York, events and hidden gems delivered weekly. Free always 🍊🧂

📩 The next issue drops this week, get on the list now!

Syracuse’s coffee scene is thriving, blending local flavor, creativity, and a strong sense of community. Here’s an in-depth look at the seven best coffee shops in Syracuse for 2025, each offering its own unique vibe, specialty drinks, and loyal following.

Best Syracuse Coffee Shops

Recess Coffee - The Neighborhood Classic That Never Misses

📍Multiple Locations:

• 110 Montgomery St #103, Syracuse, NY 13202

• 110 Harvard Pl, Syracuse, NY 13210

• 429 Ulster St, Syracuse, NY 13204

Why Go?

Recess Coffee is a true Syracuse institution, serving the city since 2007 and earning a reputation as the go-to spot for students, artists, and locals alike. Recess holds a special place in our hearts after spending many years working in the city and walking cold winter blocks to get a good cup of coffee during work. Their location on campus is one of the only coffee shops open late in the area, and the Tipp Hill location is becoming our favorite for a late breakfast or lunch.

With its commitment to sustainability and locally roasted beans, Recess has become synonymous with quality and community. The eclectic, cozy interiors, think mismatched couches, local art, and sun-dappled nooks, make it easy to settle in for hours, whether you’re working on a laptop or catching up with friends.

Their menu is a standout for anyone with dietary preferences, boasting a wide range of vegan and gluten-free pastries alongside classic favorites. The signature espresso blend is so popular that regulars buy it by the 5lb bag. Recess is more than a coffee shop; it’s a cornerstone of the neighborhood, where every cup comes with a dose of local flavor and friendly service.

Local Favorites:

• Oat Milk Latte

• Vegan pastries

• Nitro Cold Brew on tap

Kelsey’s Coffee and Friends (Originally Peaks Coffee Company) - The Modern Favorite

📍Location: 1200 E Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13210

Why Go?

Kelsey’s Coffee and Friends, formerly Peaks Coffee Company, brings a fresh, modern energy to the Syracuse coffee scene. The space is bright, minimalist, and thoughtfully designed, making it a favorite for students, remote workers, and anyone seeking a calm, inspiring environment. Kelsey’s focuses on meticulously sourced beans, with a menu that highlights the nuances of each roast, think single-origin pour-overs and creative specialty drinks with house-made syrups.

The baristas are friendly, knowledgeable, and always ready to recommend something new. Whether you’re here for a quiet morning coffee or an afternoon study session, Kelsey’s delivers a consistently high-quality experience that keeps regulars coming back.

Local Favorites:

• Pour-Over Coffee

• Oat Milk Latte

• House-made Syrups

Salt City Coffee - Where Community and Craft Collide

📍Multiple Locations:

• 484 South Salina St, Syracuse, NY 13202

• 511 E. Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066 

• 720 University Ave, Syracuse, NY 13210

• 509 W. Onondaga St, Syracuse, NY 13204

Why Go?

Salt City Coffee is the beating heart of Syracuse’s coffee renaissance, blending exceptional coffee with a deep commitment to the community. Their flagship café is housed in a beautifully restored historic building, offering a warm, inviting space that feels like a second home. Salt City’s team is passionate about every step of the coffee process, from sourcing ethically grown beans to perfecting each roast in-house. The Salt City Market location adds to the buzz, placing you in the center of one of Syracuse’s most vibrant food halls.

Here, you’ll find inventive seasonal lattes, expertly pulled espresso shots, and a staff that’s always eager to share their latest creations. Salt City Coffee isn’t just a place to grab a cup, it’s where locals gather for conversation, creativity, and a sense of belonging.

Local Favorites:

• House Drip

• Cortado

• Seasonal Lattes

Cafe Blue - The Hidden Gem with a Cozy Vibe

📍Location: 128 E Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13202

Why Go?

Cafe Blue is the kind of place you stumble upon once and instantly want to keep secret. Tucked away in downtown Syracuse, this intimate café is known for its welcoming atmosphere, creative drinks, and attention to detail. The blue-themed decor and plush seating create a sense of calm, making it the perfect spot to unwind with a book or catch up with friends.

The menu features unique specialty lattes (lavender and honey, anyone?), a rotating selection of local pastries, and some of the best chai in town. The staff takes pride in getting to know their regulars, and there’s always a new seasonal drink or treat to try. If you’re looking for a coffee shop that feels like your own personal hideaway, Cafe Blue is the answer.

Local Favorites:

• Lavender Latte

• Chai

• Blueberry Muffins

Sugar Grove Cafe & Bakery - Come for the Baked Goods

📍Location: 4671 Onondaga Blvd, Syracuse, NY 13219

Why Go?

Sugar Grove Cafe & Bakery is a family-run haven where comfort food and quality coffee go hand in hand. The space is sun-filled and homey, with the scent of fresh-baked pastries greeting you at the door. Their bakery case is always stocked with scones, muffins, and cinnamon rolls that pair perfectly with a cup of their house blend or a creative seasonal latte. Sugar Grove is beloved for its welcoming staff, who treat every guest like family, and its commitment to using fresh, local ingredients.

It’s the kind of place where you can linger over breakfast, enjoy a leisurely lunch, or pop in for a sweet treat and a pick-me-up. If you crave a coffee shop that feels like a warm hug, Sugar Grove delivers.

Local Favorites:

• Cinnamon Roll Latte

• Scones

• House Blend Coffee

The Cracked Bean Roastery & Cafe - The Roaster’s Choice

📍Location: 4530 Apulia Rd, Jamesville, NY 13078

Why Go?

The Cracked Bean Roastery & Cafe is a destination for true coffee aficionados. Located just outside Syracuse in Jamesville, this small-batch roaster is obsessed with quality, sourcing beans from around the world and roasting them to perfection on-site. The rustic, wood-accented café is a peaceful retreat, perfect for sipping a single-origin pour-over or sampling an espresso flight. The staff is passionate about coffee education, always happy to chat about the origins and flavor profiles of their latest roasts.

The Cracked Bean also offers freshly roasted beans to take home, so you can enjoy their expertly crafted coffee wherever you are. For those who appreciate the craft behind every cup, this spot is a must-visit.

Local Favorites:

• Single-Origin Pour-Over

• Espresso Flight

• Freshly Roasted Beans (to go)

Cafe Kubal - The Syracuse Coffee Pioneer

📍Multiple locations:

• 2218 E Colvin St, Syracuse, NY 13210

• 324 W. Water St, Syracuse, NY 13202

• 3501 James St, Syracuse, NY 13206

• 401 S Salina St, Syracuse, NY 13202

• 3911 Brewerton Rd, Syracuse, NY 13212

• 27 E Genesee St, Auburn, NY 13021

Why Go?

Cafe Kubal is the original pioneer of Syracuse’s specialty coffee movement, with a legacy that stretches back to 2004. With several locations across the city, Kubal is known for its ethically sourced beans, expertly trained baristas, and inviting, sunlit spaces. Their commitment to quality shows in every detail, from the rich, complex flavors of their signature espresso to their inventive house-made syrups.

The food menu is equally impressive, featuring local favorites and healthy options like avocado toast and breakfast bowls. Kubal is a favorite for everyone from students to professionals, offering a welcoming environment for meetings, study sessions, or just a quiet moment with a great cup of coffee. If you want to experience the roots of Syracuse’s coffee culture, Kubal is the place to start.

Local Favorites:

• Honey Almond Latte

• Nitro Cold Brew

Syracuse’s coffee shops are more than places to grab a cup—they’re vibrant community hubs, each with its own story and style. Whether you’re after the legendary espresso at Recess, the modern vibes at Kelsey’s, or the cozy comfort of Sugar Grove, these seven spots offer the best of Syracuse’s coffee culture.

Want more local food guides like this? Sign up for TLDR Syracuse and get the best of Syracuse, New York, restaurants, bakeries, events, and hidden gems, delivered weekly. Free always 🍊🧂

📩 The next issue drops this week, get on the list now!